Portugal opposes Welsh alcohol price hike plans

in News · 12-07-2019 01:00:00 · 1 Comments
Portugal opposes Welsh alcohol price hike plans

Portugal is concerned that a minimum price rate for alcohol will make its products less competitive in the Welsh markets.

Portugal has expressed its concern about the Welsh plans of enforcing a minimum price for alcoholic drinks. The measure would charge 50p a unit, which, according to the BBC, would mean that a bottle of wine would cost at least £4.69.

The price minimum was expected to come into force this summer, but Portugal’s opposition has hindered the plan in Wales.

The Welsh government had planned to impose this summer a minimum price of 50 pence (€0.56) per unit of alcohol to combat the harmful effects of alcohol consumption.

In a written statement published on 29 May, Wales’ minister of health and social services, Vaughan Gething, said he received a notification from a member state of the European Union (EU) with an opinion on the draft law.

“The effect of this is that the standstill period was extended by another three months, which means that it was extended until 21 August,” he said, so it will not be possible to end the legislative process until the beginning of 2020.

On Monday, BBC said that this delay was due to an opinion from Portugal’s minister of economy, as part of a procedure allowing EU member states to oppose plans of other EU countries.

The measure to be implemented provides for a bottle of wine to cost at least £4.69 (€5.24), which the Portuguese authorities feared would have “direct implications” for the competitiveness of national products and the free trade rules of the EU market.

“There are Portuguese operators who export wines to Wales whose consumer price is lower than the minimum price, therefore the application of a minimum unit price means that many of these wines will go up in price, which will make them less competitive in that market,” the minister said, according to the BBC.

The document questioned whether the minimum unit plans area proportional policy response and called for more evidence to prove they have “the desired effect for public health in the long term.”

Portugal called for “concerted policies and strategies,” to promote moderate alcohol consumption and to clarify the effects of the excessive consumption of alcohol, “It is thus possible to safeguard the issue of public health and at the same time (comply) with the principle of the free movement of goods.”

Welsh policymakers defend the measure based on health reasons, claiming that the fee could save one life a week and avoid one thousand four hundred yearly hospital admissions.

Vaughan Gething, Wales’ Health Minister is positive about the enforcement of the measure, believing it will come into force by 2020.


Scotland introduced minimum alcohol pricing and it has had no beneficial effect. It was supposed to reduce alcohol consumption but has actually had the opposite effect.
This is just another example of the nanny state, where politicians with nothing else to do, and who seem to think that they have a god given right to punish every citizen who likes a glass of wine now and again.
This policy didn’t work in Scotland and I am sure that it won’t work in Wales either.

by David Phin from Porto on 12-07-2019 07:45:00
Interactive Topics, send us your comments/opinion on this article.

Please note that The Portugal News may use selected comments in the printed edition of the newspaper.